William Merritt Chase: A Reputation Takes Shape
By: Adam Veil, VP, Head of Department, American Art and Pennsylvania Impressionists
William Merritt Chase painted this portrait while studying in Munich, where he arrived in 1872 after a brief stint at the National Academy of Design in New York. The Munich Royal Academy proved to be his true training ground, and it was here that Chase came to the attention of Karl Theodore von Piloty (1826–1886), the Academy’s director and a leading history painter of the day. Piloty commissioned Chase to paint portraits of his five children—a commission significant enough to be reported in The New York Times, and very likely a welcome piece of publicity for the young American artist. This canvas, depicting one of Piloty’s three daughters, is the only one of the five to have been located.
The portrait reflects the double character of Chase’s Munich years. Much of what he absorbed there was the school’s characteristically loose, “slapdash” brushwork, seen at its most exuberant in Keying Up: The Court Jester (1875). But Chase was simultaneously developing a subtler, more refined manner of his own—fine modeling, restrained gesture, a quieter kind of authority—and the present work belongs to that second strand. The girl stands against a dark, atmospheric ground, her hands clasped before her, her gaze turning back toward the viewer. A gray double- breasted coat and ruffled white collar are set off by a single note of color: a pink scarf knotted at her throat.
The date of the painting is not incidental. Chase painted it in 1877, the same year as Ready for the Ride, the picture critics would later single out as his “strongest” and, decades on, “equal to any portrait ever painted by an American.” That success is thought to have directly prompted Piloty’s commission, and the two works share the same refined idiom, setting them apart from Chase’s looser, more theatrical Munich exercises. Painted, in other words, at the very moment Chase’s reputation was taking shape, Portrait of a Young Lady (Portrait of Piloty’s Daughter) leads Freeman’s marquee American Art & Pennsylvania Impressionists auction on December 8.
