Historic Washington Portrait and 1932 Martin & Co. Guitar Lead Freeman’s to a Staggering $2.3M Fall American Furniture, Folk and Decorative Arts Auction
A historic portrait of George Washington by the important portrait artist Gilbert Stuart and an exceedingly rare 1932 C.F. Martin & Co. guitar headlined Freeman’s $2.3 million American Furniture, Folk and Decorative Arts auction. The November 12 auction more than doubled its presale estimate with exceptional results from every corner of the category as miniature portraiture, silver, furniture, porcelain, folk and fine art all saw lots vault past their presale estimates.
A Familiar Face
The top lot of the auction was an Athenaeum-type Gilbert Stuart (American, 1755-1828) portrait of George Washington (lot 18), which set the tone early, selling for $1 million against an estimate of $100,000 to $200,000. Likely painted in the final decade of the artist's life, Stuart’s portrait of his signature subject, Washington, was one of at least three paintings commissioned by the wealthy Sears family of Boston. During this period, the demand for Stuart portraits of the first president was steady, and the artist created numerous likenesses of Washington using an unfinished canvas of the founding father taken from life in Philadelphia in 1796 as reference. That unfinished canvas would come to be known as the “Athenaeum Portrait” and was the basis of Washington’s portrait on the one-dollar bill. It is currently jointly owned by the Boston Museum of Fine Arts and the National Portrait Gallery.
The portrait was the crown jewel of the offerings from the Estate of Ambassador J. William Middendorf II, which led off the auction. Middendorf was a singular figure whose influence spanned finance, government, the military, and the arts. Alongside his professional and civic achievements, he cultivated a discerning eye as a collector.
Middendorf was a Navy veteran and co-founder of the investment banking firm Middendorf, Colgate and Company, with a seat on the New York Stock Exchange before turning to public service. Middendorf, however, was best known for his public service, becoming one of the most frequently appointed American diplomats of his era. He advised five presidents – Eisenhower, Nixon, Ford, Carter, and Reagan – and served as ambassador to the Netherlands, the Organization of American States, and the European Community, as well as Secretary of the Navy from 1974 to 1977.
Middendorf was also an accomplished composer, artist, and author. In his lifetime, he composed at least 80 marches for Navy ships, 17 anthems dedicated to nations across the hemisphere, operas, and eight symphonies, and he received the American Bandmasters Association’s Edwin Franko Goldman Award. A lifelong draftsman, he filled 620 sketchbooks with more than 10,000 drawings. It’s no wonder, then, that Rhode Island Senate Minority Leader Jessica de la Cruz once called him a “Renaissance man.”

Lot 293 | A Rare and Important 1932 C.F. Martin & Co. Model 000-42S, Serial No. 52361
Custom order by the Rudolph Wurlitzer Co., New York
$50,000 – 100,000
A Rare Musical Treasure Returns Home
The other headliner from the auction was an exceptionally rare and important 1932 C.F. Martin & Co. Model 000-42S six string guitar (lot 293), that quadrupled its presale estimate selling for $217,600. Four phone bidders battled seven online bidders for the honor of bringing the rare musical treasure home with them and ultimately, the guitar found its way back home, selling to C.F. Martin & Company where it will be placed on view in their museum alongside original correspondence ordering this unique instrument.
“It was a true pleasure to get to handle such a remarkable piece of American music history,” said Ben Fisher, Freeman’s Managing Director of Decorative Arts. “We are thrlled that the guitar is returning home to C.F. Martin. It’s fitting that such a beautiful piece should be made available to the world to admire.”
In November 1932, the acoustic guitar was custom-ordered by the Rudolph Wurlitzer Co. in New York City at the request of a private client. At the time it was ordered, Wurlitzer was one of the few authorized retailers of Martin guitars.
There is beautiful and understated abalone inlay around the top of the body, extending around the fingerboard, and around the sound hole. There is additional wood inlay on the front and back of the body. As is the custom with Martin guitars, the model and serial numbers are stamped to the inside of the body, on the neck block.

Lot 140 | A Revolutionary / War of 1812 Bronze Cannon, Possibly from Paul Revere's Foundry
SOLD FOR $60,800
Other Highlights
- Lot 140 | A Revolutionary / War of 1812 Bronze Cannon, Possibly from Paul Revere's Foundry
Possibly Canton, Massachusetts, Circa 1794-1815
SOLD FOR $60,800 - Lot 90 | A Group of Livingston/ Ridley Family items: A George III Sterling Salver and Three English School 18th Century Portrait Miniatures
SOLD FOR $41,600 - Lot 303 | A Polychrome Painted Cast Zinc Goddess of Liberty Figure
Attributed to William DeMuth & Co., New York, Circa 1880
SOLD FOR $41,600 - Lot 253 | A Tiffany & Co. Silver Seven Piece Tea and Coffee Service, plus Tray
New York, Late 19th/Early 20th Century
SOLD FOR $35,200 - Lot 89 | Charles Willson Peale (1741-1827)
Portrait Miniature of Catharine Livingston Ridley Livingston (1751-1813)
SOLD FOR $21,760 - Lot 88 | Charles Willson Peale (1741-1827)
Portrait Miniature of Susannah Livingston Symmes (1748-1840)
SOLD FOR $15,360 - Lot 54 | A William & Mary Blue-Painted Two-Drawer Blanket Chest
New England, Circa 1720
SOLD FOR $7,040
About Freeman’s
Freeman’s is a premier American auction house offering services in multiple categories including fine art, jewelry, design, books and manuscripts, furniture, decorative arts, antiquities, couture, and Asian works of art. With 14 regional locations nationwide, the firm provides auctions, appraisals, private sales, and art advisory services, connecting clients to the global art market. Freeman’s strives to bring art, history, and design to life by connecting people with extraordinary objects through exceptional service and expertise.
