HERBERT, FRANK Two proof copies of works by Herbert, comprising: (1) Whipping star. New York: Berkley Medallon, 1970. First paperback edition, with typescript note from Herbert to a Berkley editor David Hartwell stapled to front cover: "Please note corrections in book and insert notes." With dozens of Herbert's manuscript annotations throughoutt he text. Also included: (2) an uncorrected proof for The Dosadi experiment. New York: Putnam's Sons / Berkley, 1977. With only minor discoloration to front wrapper, otherwise in fine condition.