Theodore Earl Butler

(American, 1861–1936)

Sailboats, Upper Bay, New York

, 1917

oil on canvas

signed T.E. Butler and dated (lower right)

32 x 39 3/4 inches.

Property from a Florida Collection

This lot is located in Chicago.

This painting will be included in Patrick Bertrand's forthcoming catalogue raisonné of the work of Theodore Earl Butler. We are grateful for his assistance cataloging this lot.

Provenance:

Estate of the Artist

Jean Marie Toulgouat, the Artist's grandson

Art Giverny, Oakland, California

Purchased from the above by the present owner, 1994

Exhibited:

(probably) Schwartz Gallery, New York, February 21 - March 21, 1921

Lot note:

Composed of shifting blues, greens, and pinks, Sailboats, Upper Bay, New York, 1917, masterfully conveys the kinetic quality of water juxtaposed against a fog-filled New York City. Rather than focusing his attention on the mass of skyscrapers on the southern tip of Manhattan, Theodore Earl Butler concentrated on the combined effects of water, reflection, light, and color playing off the white-tipped waves that appear to splash dynamically around the detailed three-masted ships in the foreground. The artist used a variety of brushwork, with smoother strokes for the sky, haze, and tall buildings that act as a foil to the strong, curving strokes used for the flickering water and clear lines of the ships. The effect dissolves all shapes in space uniformly, creating a filmy, chromatic atmosphere that shimmers and flickers across the luminous canvas. A very similar composition, also titled Sailboats, Upper Bay (location unknown), was executed by the artist the same year.

Butler had previously depicted the New York Harbor in other artworks, when he returned to the United States in 1900 after the death of his wife, Suzanne Hoschedé in 1899. Originally from Columbus, Ohio, the artist moved to Paris in 1885 to study. In 1888, he accompanied his friend and fellow artist Theodore Robinson to Giverny to join the community of American Impressionists who lived in the area to near Claude Monet. Under the influence of one of the original impressionists, Butler began to paint garden scenes and studies of figures posed outdoors, using loose strokes with a brightly colored palette. It was also through Monet that Butler was introduced to Suzanne, the older artist’s stepdaughter and favorite model. Butler also met Blanche Hoschedé, Suzanne’s sister, who painted Jardin en fleurs (Les rosiers) (Lot 15), also included in the present sale and which comes from the same collection.

The drastic change between the bucolic landscape of Giverny and the dramatic hustle and bustle of New York clearly inspired the artist. He had lived in New York before moving to Europe and the city had changed greatly in the intervening time. Butler was only to stay for six months, but during that time he produced some of his most acclaimed artworks. Like these earlier views of New York, the present work is done in Butler’s particular combination of impressionist colors and brushwork with postimpressionist abstract, flattened forms and patterning. The uniqueness of his imagery did not go unnoticed. An article published in the New York Times, March 21, 1921, mentioned the city subjects painted by the artist, “…the latter carrying the honors. It would be hard to find a more beautiful views of the city in the warm afternoon light.”

Framed: 38 3/4 x 46 1/2 inches.

The physical condition of lots in our auctions can vary due to age, normal wear and tear, previous damage, and restoration/repair. All lots are sold "AS IS," in the condition they are in at the time of the auction, and we and the seller make no representation or warranty and assume no liability of any kind as to a lot's condition. Any reference to condition in a catalogue description or a condition report shall not amount to a full accounting of condition. Condition reports prepared by Freeman's staff are provided as a convenience and may be requested from the Department prior to bidding.

The absence of a posted condition report on the Freeman's website or in our catalogues should not be interpreted as commentary on an item's condition. Prospective buyers are responsible for inspecting a lot or sending their agent or conservator to inspect the lot on their behalf, and for ensuring that they have requested, received and understood any condition report provided by Freeman's.

Please email [email protected] for any additional information or questions you may have regarding this lot.

To request further details about this lot, please email [email protected]

Please contact the Auction Specialist for details.

Joseph Stanfield

Senior Vice President, Director, Fine Art

[email protected]312.280.1212

As the head of Hindman’s Fine Art Department, Mr. Stanfield is instrumental in bringing in major consignments from private collectors, estates, dealers and institutions. He has led the department to dozens of auction records, with a particular focus on Chicago Modernism. Mr. Stanfield has played an integral role in the development of the American & European and Post War & Contemporary Art categories, with the most successful year for the department in company history coming in 2021. He also oversaw a house record for total sales for a week of Fine Art auctions in May 2022. Mr. Stanfield is also the lead auctioneer for the Fine Art sales at Hindman. Prior to returning to Hindman in 2019, he was at Toomey & Co. for eight years, where he oversaw important collections including the estate of Candice B. Groot, the collection of Governor Jim Thompson, and the estate of Robert E. Beck. Mr. Stanfield earned a BA from the University of Kansas where he studied Art History.

Madalina Lazen

VP Head of Department, Old Masters & 19th Century European Art

[email protected]561.833.8053

Ms. Lazen comes to Freeman's with over 25 years of experience in the fine art industry. She joined the firm in 2022 after working as Vice President, Specialist 19th Century European Paintings at Sotheby’s New York, spending a total of nearly 14 years at the auction house. Ms. Lazen also served as Director 19th Century Paintings at Bonhams New York for nearly ten years. Her focus is on Old Masters, 19th Century European Art, and Impressionism.

We are open for pick-up Monday-Friday: 9am-4:30pm.

For questions about shipping or packing, please contact [email protected] or see our Shipping/Packing page.